VA home loans · Licensed in AZ, CA, FL & TX Call Today! (480) 203-6263
VetsInHomes

Where VA deals actually die

VetsInHomes

Call Today! (480) 203-6263

The VA appraisal, and the repairs that kill deals

The appraisal is the one step in a VA purchase that is genuinely different — and the one place an unprepared agent loses a veteran the house. Almost everything it flags is predictable before you write the offer.

Ryan Mandley NMLS #1181993 | WeFund NMLS #2518287 · Licensed in AZ, CA, FL & TX · Equal Housing Opportunity

  • Two jobsestablishes value and checks the property
  • VA-assignedthe lender does not pick the appraiser
  • Escape clauseyou can walk if value comes in low
  • Predictablemost MPR flags are visible from the driveway
  • NMLS #1181993
  • Equal Housing Lender
  • Licensed AZ · CA · FL · TX
  • No call centers
  • Answer in 1 business day

Last reviewed September 2026 by Ryan Mandley, VA Loan Specialist · NMLS #1181993

What the VA appraisal is, and is not

A VA appraisal does two things at once. It establishes the property's value, and it confirms the home meets VA's Minimum Property Requirements — that the place is safe, structurally sound and sanitary. The result is a Notice of Value, which may come with conditions that must be cleared before closing.

Two things it is not:

  • It is not a home inspection. An appraiser is not crawling the attic or testing every outlet. Get your own inspection. The appraisal protects VA's interest and yours only incidentally.
  • It is not your lender's opinion. VA assigns the appraiser from its own panel. Your lender cannot choose a friendly one, and cannot lean on the result. That independence is the point.

The Minimum Property Requirements that actually cause trouble

MPRs are not a high bar — ordinary homes clear them all day. The recurring flags are these:

  • Roof condition. Not age alone, but remaining life and active leaks. A roof at the end of its life is the most common single problem.
  • Peeling or chipping paint on homes built before 1978, because of lead paint rules. This kills more deals than any structural issue, and it is visible from the sidewalk.
  • Working mechanical systems. Heat that works, safe electrical, functional plumbing, no major leaks.
  • Water and sewer. A safe, continuous water supply and sanitary disposal. Private wells and septic systems are allowed but come with their own tests and rules.
  • Access. The property needs safe, permanent access from a street; private-road properties need a recorded maintenance agreement.
  • Wood-destroying insects. Inspection requirements vary by state; who may pay for it is governed by VA’s state-by-state fee rules.
  • Bare-earth crawl spaces, exposed wiring, missing handrails, broken windows. Small, cheap, and enough to hold up a closing when nobody saw them coming.

The fix is timing, not luck. Walk a property with these in mind before you write, and most MPR issues become a negotiation item in the contract instead of a surprise three weeks in. That is a thing a lender who does this constantly can do for you on a phone call.

When the value comes in low

VA purchase contracts include an amendatory clause: if the appraised value comes in below the contract price, you may walk away and keep your earnest money. That protection is federal and it is not negotiable away.

Walking is only one of four options:

  • Renegotiate. The seller lowers the price to the appraised value. Common, especially when the buyer pool is thin.
  • Request a Reconsideration of Value. Submit better comparable sales or correct factual errors in the report. VA has a formal ROV process, and a well-documented request does succeed.
  • Bring the difference in cash. You may pay the gap between value and price. Financing is based on the lower of the two.
  • Walk. Under the amendatory clause, with your deposit.

What you cannot do is finance above the appraised value. That is the whole reason the clause exists.

Tidewater: the warning most buyers never hear about

Tidewater is a VA process where an appraiser who is heading toward a value below the contract price notifies the parties before finalizing. It opens a short window — usually a couple of days — for the agents to submit additional comparable sales supporting the price.

It is a real opportunity and it is routinely wasted, because the notice arrives while nobody is expecting it and the window closes. If your agent and lender are paying attention, the right comps go in on time. If they are not, you find out later that you had a chance you did not use.

Timing and cost

The appraisal is ordered early, usually right after the contract is signed and the file is set up. Turn times vary by market and by how busy the VA panel is locally; rural assignments generally take longer than metro ones.

The fee is set by VA for each region — it is not a number your lender marks up — and it is customarily paid by the buyer, though it can be negotiated like other costs. See VA loan closing costs for what you can and cannot be charged.

One more thing worth knowing: a VA appraisal stays with the property for a set period. If your deal falls apart, the next VA buyer generally inherits that value, which is a good reason to understand exactly what happened before assuming a re-list means a fresh start.

Verify any of this yourself

Nothing here should be taken on faith, including from me. The primary sources:

Vets In Homes is not affiliated with or endorsed by the U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs. Program rules change — verify current details at va.gov.


Found a house and not sure it will clear a VA appraisal? Send me the listing before you write the offer. That review takes five minutes and saves whole deals.

Have Ryan look at it

Straight answers

Appraisal questions

How long does a VA appraisal take?

It varies by market and by how busy the local VA panel is — metro assignments are usually quicker than rural ones. It is ordered early precisely because it is the step least under anyone’s control.

Who pays for the VA appraisal?

Customarily the buyer, at a fee VA sets for the region. Like other costs, it can be negotiated with the seller as part of the contract.

Can the seller refuse to make MPR repairs?

Yes. Then the options are a price renegotiation, someone else paying for the repair, or walking. In some cases the buyer may pay for repairs, though there are rules about which ones — this is a case-by-case conversation.

Does a VA appraisal take the place of a home inspection?

No, and treating it that way is a real mistake. The appraisal protects the lender and VA. A home inspection protects you, costs a few hundred dollars, and finds things the appraisal never looks at.

What is a Notice of Value?

The document reporting the appraised value plus any conditions that must be satisfied before the loan can close. Conditions are normal; they are a to-do list, not a rejection.

Can I buy a fixer-upper with a VA loan?

A standard VA loan needs a habitable property, so a true gut rehab is not a fit. Cosmetic work is fine. There are VA renovation options, but they are limited and not every lender offers them.

Do sellers avoid VA offers because of the appraisal?

Some listing agents still believe old myths about VA appraisals being slow or picky. A strong underwritten pre-approval and a lender who will call the listing agent directly resolves most of that objection.


Talk to a person

Have a property reviewed before you write

Send me the address or the listing link. I will tell you what an appraiser is likely to flag and what to put in the contract so it does not become your problem later.

  • No cost, no obligation — and no credit pull to start the conversation.
  • Use the VA benefit you earned — with no monthly mortgage insurance, ever.
  • Licensed in AZ, CA, FL & TX — one lender across your sale and your purchase.
  • Straight answers. If a VA loan is the wrong tool for your situation, I will say so.

Would rather just talk?
(480) 203-6263

Stop Cryin Call Ryan

VetsInHomes

Call Today! (480) 203-6263

See what you qualify for

Answer a few quick questions. It takes about 60 seconds and there is no credit pull.

Ryan Mandley NMLS #1181993 | WeFund NMLS #2518287 · Licensed in AZ, CA, FL & TX · Equal Housing Opportunity

Check my eligibility Call Ryan